'The Magic School Bus Rides Again' is a dull but inoffensive nostalgia cruise
by Tanner Kinney
If there’s one thing millennials love, it’s remakes of things from their childhoods. From the iconic horror mini-series It to educational television like Bill Nye the Science Guy, if it came out during the 80’s or 90’s and had relative success, people want to see it again. It’s not a bad idea either; these shows or movies are often held back by the technology of the time. Using modern tech, they can be re-imagined the way they were intended. Educational shows also get the benefit of new discoveries that can be implemented into the remake. However, sometimes it can seem like there is no purpose for the remake. That’s where The Magic School Bus Rides Again falls; it’s a nice nostalgia trip but, other than that, there’s no real reason for it to exist.
Art direction that took a few wrong turns
From even the first moments, it’s obvious there’s something wrong with The Magic School Bus Rides Again. The theme song is exactly the same as the original and the scenes are almost identical to the original in structure but there’s something missing. That would be the art style. It’s hard to really describe what feels so wrong about it, but it immediately creates the feeling that this isn’t the same show. The art is uninspired and lazy. The original show was inexpensive and made for kids so there were plenty of animation mistakes but it had style and heart in it. This is possibly due to the original being hand-drawn. It’s not necessarily clean or shiny but it’s real. Just comparing the two openings, it’s clear that there was more effort put into the animation of the original. The bus moves like a character, bouncing around with weight to it. The original’s art style felt human.
The Magic School Bus Rides Again has this clean, computer generated aesthetic that looks no different than a show like Wild Kratts or other kid’s shows. Even when comparing it to other cartoons there’s nothing visually impressive to note. Shows like Adventure Time or Steven Universe have wonderful, unique art styles that make the shows interesting to watch for both kids and adults. Magic School Bus Rides Again, on the other hand, looks cheap by comparison. In the 13 episodes of the show, there wasn’t a single moment that stood out as something amazing. It all just blended together into a bland mush. Again, compare the openings. The remake’s is almost identical to the original but the animation just has no real weight or movement to it. It’s unsettling, and hurts the nostalgia value for the show. The closest the show gets to having the art do something interesting is during the comic book sequences in episode four. They could’ve done a much better job capturing the spirit of the original’s art while making its own art style.
Educational content that revs the show alive
It’s hard to really judge a kid’s show by the same standards as something meant to entertain an adult. Yes, The Magic School Bus Rides Again is a kid’s show even if it was marketed at millennials. That’s one thing the show does right: it maintains the educational style and value of the original. The content of the episodes (ignoring the animation) fits right along with the original series. Some episodes repeat concepts from the original, but there were things that were definitely new and wouldn’t have been considered important for kids to learn in the past. A major surprise was episode two’s focus on structural engineering, which is not something expected of a modern kid’s show. As a side note, it’s also admirable that the show completely avoids controversial or political subjects, sticking just to learning. Other reboots could learn a thing or two from this show. At the end of the day, kids would likely gain knowledge from watching this show.
One segment that never fails to ring true to the show's educational aspect is the closing segments with the classic Ms. Frizzle (voiced by Lily Tomlin, the original voice actress). These were in the originals as well, and served to clear up inconsistencies between reality and the cartoon world. The remake completely aces these segments, providing both knowledge and entertainment. It could be just because Lily Tomlin’s Ms. Frizzle is familiar, but that blast of nostalgia is a welcome addition to the end of every episode. Even if it’s hard to sit through the episode (sometimes it really is), the nostalgic light at the end of the tunnel makes it all worth it.
Entertainment value that sputters along
When a show like The Magic School Bus Ride Again wants to be “edutainment” , the overall enjoyment of the show is very important. This is the hardest part to really rate. The show is probably entertaining for children. Its writing is almost identical to the original, with some additions like selfies being added to keep up with the times. Fortunately, the kids aren’t saying things like “it’s lit” or “turn up” or whatever the youths these days say. It’s all very normal kid stuff with dialogue that’s written to create kids who are incredibly smart and dull. There are puns, jokes and visual gags that would probably make a kid laugh out loud. The original was also very plain like this with similar writing that was enjoyable for children.
The problem comes from identifying who The Magic School Bus Rides Again is for. If this show is supposed to be an entertaining nostalgia trip for a millennial, it falls short. Sure, the writing is identical and that deserves respect, but that doesn’t make it any more entertaining as a person who claims to be an adult but is really more of a man-child. The only episodes that provided entertainment value outside of nostalgic moments were episodes four and nine. For those who want the Magic School Bus experience that’s still entertaining for a millennial, those two would be the best ones to watch. The rest of it is just not funny aside from lines obviously directed at the adults watching, which can either make the viewer laugh or cringe. And no, self-referential humor does not save the show. It just serves as a reminder of how great things were back in the good ole days. Nostalgia alone cannot serve as the entertainment of a show.
Featured image from TechCrunch