Our View: Celebrity opinions

ATISSUE:Public responses to celebrity war opinions should be critical, not knee-jerking

Whether supporting or protesting President Bush and the war in Iraq, the opinions of celebrities recently have come to public attention.

Sadly, most public reactions have been of the knee-jerk variety.

Natalie Maines, lead singer of the Dixie Chicks, voiced opposition, saying, "Just so you know, we're ashamed the president of the United States is from Texas." Although Maines made this comment to a European audience, the Dixie Chicks were immediately met with American radio station and fan boycotts.

Despite the Chicks' current hit "Travelin' Soldier," which is decidedly anti-war and pro-soldier at the same time, fans burned Dixie Chicks concert tickets and compact discs to show their objection to Maines' remarks. Maines publicly apologized to the president and to her fans in a written statement, saying her feelings were those of a concerned mother and proud American.

Actor George Clooney also voiced opposition, saying, "The government itself is running exactly like the Sopranos." This is the same George Clooney who portrayed a Gulf War soldier in the 1999 film "Three Kings" -- one of the few serious films that took an anti-Saddam, pro-America stance while still remaining somewhat sympathetic to the Iraqi people. Contradictory, perhaps, but poignant nonetheless (Clooney is an actor, after all).

Perhaps the most striking quote came from actor Bruce Willis, best known for his roles in the "Die Hard" series, but also the star of "Hart's War," "Tears of the Sun" and "The Siege." (He played a soldier in all three of the latter.)

"Just because we're actors isn't reason to give us a voice on these issues more than anyone else," Willis said.

Good point, but let's get this straight.

Celebrities can release catchy songs and portray compelling characters in poignant, politically charged films, but the minute they take a personal stand, the public divides and launches into varied protests?

Do Dixie Chicks fans not listen to lyrics or interpret songs? Did "Three Kings" viewers miss the film's message?

Celebrities wield a great power of influence -- some more than politicians. Without doubt, there is strong support for the views of all of the above.

However, during a time of war, both pro-war and pro-peace advocates can inflict serious damage by discrediting the views of celebrities.

When American celebrities voice opinions, don't immediately discount them, and don't knee-jerk by boycotting their work. To be a fan of certain celebrities is not necessarily to be complicit with their views.

Consider celebrity views critically, regardless of what they are, and remember:

They're just as American as you are, and they have every right to support or dissent.


Comments

More from The Daily






Loading Recent Classifieds...